Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | slig2's commentslogin

You probably can't do it, because 80 respects robots.txt AFAIK.


Any guesses of how much this would cost to do on EC2?


With some handwaving it could be about $82.5K (computation spread over 1 year) or $125K (computation done in 1 month).

  total cost was 35 CPU years (Intel Nehalem, 4-core, 2.8GHz)
  1 EC2 compute unit is about 1 GHz Xeon
  let's assume 1 Google unit = 12 EC2 units (3x4 cores)
  High-CPU Extra Large instance = 20 EC2 units

  35*12 = 420 EC2 unit years = 5040 EC2 unit months
  =  21 HiCPU XL instances for 1 year
  = 252 HiCPU XL instances for 1 month
Putting this into AWS calculator [1] yields:

   $82,491.36 (21 HiCPU XL reserved instances for 1 year)
  $125,435.52 (252 HiCPU XL on-demand instances for 1 month)
[1] http://calculator.s3.amazonaws.com/calc5.html

------

Edit: It could be actually a bit more, Nehalems seem to be faster than my first estimate.

Plugging in EC2 computing unit comparison from Cluster Compute instance (which has 2x quadcore Nehalem), 1 Google unit can be 16.75 EC2 units.

This gives:

  $114K for 1 year of 29 reserved HiCPU XL instances
  $166K for 1 year of 18 reserved cluster compute instances

  $173K for 1 month of 348 on-demand HiCPU XL instances
  $246K for 1 month of 210 on-demand cluster compute instances
-----

Edit2: Dedicated server hosting would be much cheaper. For example, from Hetzner [2] it would cost just about 26K EUR (= $34K) to rent 35 dedicated quadcore Nehalem servers for 1 year.

[2] http://www.hetzner.de/en/hosting/produktmatrix/rootserver-pr...


Roughly $43000, using spot-instances.

Back of the envelope... From the link, it would take

  1.1 billion seconds @ 4x 2.8ghz
	= 4.4 billion @ 2.8 Ghz
	= 12.32 billion seconds @ 1 Ghz = ~3430000 hours
Using ec2 unit performance as 1Ghz, assume computing is comparable, Ghz for Ghz (it isn't...), and storage and xfer is negligible.

Normal instances

  instance-size|ec2units | $/hr  | $ total
  sm              | 1    | 0.085 | 291550
  large           | 4    | 0.34  | 291550
  xl              | 8    | 0.50  | 214375
  himem-xl        | 6.5  | 0.69  | 364108
  himem-double-xl | 13   | 1.20  | 316615
  himem-quad      | 26   | 2.40  | 316615
  hicpu-med       | 5    | 0.17  | 116620
  hicpu-xl        | 20   | 0.68  | 116620
  cluster         | 33.5 | 1.60  | 163821
  Using spot instances             
  sm              | 1    | 0.031 | 106330
  large           | 4    | 0.14  | 120050
  xl              | 8    | 0.245 | 105044
  himem-xl        | 6.5  | 0.172 | 90763.1
  himem-double-xl | 13   | 0.427 | 112662
  himem-quad      | 26   | 0.871 | 114905
  hicpu-med       | 5    | 0.06  | 41160
  hicpu-xl        | 20   | 0.249 | 42703.5


I'm looking for someone who could build an generator similar to this one: http://www.mensus.net/brain/logic.shtml

It's not that trivial, so I don't think that using some random dude from a freelancing site would be viable.


How should people contact you? There's no email address in your publicly visible profile.


I made this account because my other one was on non-procastinaio mode. I was also hoping that someone would reply to me and then I would contact him. Thanks for the heads up.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: