Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not just MS, RAD tools were the big thing about 20 years ago

Total failure,

From reading the comments here, sounds like the no-code, the rebranded RAD, has the exact same problems again.



Back in the day RAD tools created forms with fixed layout, fixed sizes. Everyone used similar computers with similar displays. There were some simple ways to create windows with dynamic size, but those were very primitive and most dialogs were fixed.

Creating fixed UI is extremely easy to understand. You just put a control, snap it to grid for consistent spacings and that's about it. Everyone can do it, very fast with very little time spent on UI.

Modern computers are highly variable in size. Small smartphones, large smartphones, tablets of all sizes, laptops, 5K mac displays.

Smartphones and tablets expect full-width applications. It's not appropriate to design your UI for 320 px fixed width. It'll be too terrible on larger phones. It's expected to have fully stretchable UI at least.

But that leads to very complex to understand creator UI. Xcode, Android Studio, Java Swing. They have powerful layouts, but their GUI to build those layouts are incredibly complex. You might spend lots of time for very simple thing. It's nowhere near good old Delphi, when I could put few buttons around and call it a day.

Of course I'm not arguing that layout managers are not needed. Another feature is internationalization and it was terrible with Delphi, when you had to translate a button but translated text could not fit into its fixed width. What I want to point out is that there's still unfulfilled need for layout manager, which is powerful, yet very easy to use.

May be we need some AI for that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: