Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

For what it’s worth MDL, the digital driver’s license, has this baked in unless the standard changed since I paid attention - your identity authority signs a record saying >18 and >21 (+ photo) and that’s what’s transmitted.


Qld government spent $18m making its own digital license app ignoring that Apple and Google both implement the iso specification for digital ID protection. I've had two interactions online with sw people convinced "they did it better" and I am buggered if I can tell how.


Typically what happens is that consultants implement the IT systems for these departments. Unfortunately it wouldn’t surprise me if the government got snowed into thinking they needed this app / there are kickbacks involved behind the purchasing decision.

Still, it is possible the app has a legit reason like the OS wallet implementation is missing support for their region or OS wallet support is incomplete in some way and this bridges that gap.

18m does seems a tad steep though considering that RDW payed UDL to build a sample reference app for free and one would expect that to be the basis for any 3p implementation delivered. Like that would be 36 very highly paid engineers which is a lot for 2 apps. It’s possible the 18m was also for the backend changes to enable the app which would maybe be more legit and be required changes for the builtin integration. Are you sure it was 18m just for the app?


No. I misremembered, it's $53m AUD

https://www.themandarin.com.au/233815-queensland-digital-lic...

That's probably total development and some operations costs


Yeah and likely not just the app but also the backend infra to support the signing and whatnot.

It’s a shame that there’s so many disparate motor vehicle agencies. They should standardize their IT solutions to amortize development costs as I fear the vendors they pay double dip with the pricing of solutions.


What they should do is create one and publish it under an open source license so the others can use it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: